Fantasy Archives - The Litertarian

Book Review:: The Gray Sheep | S. M. Somerset

The Gray Sheep by S.M. Somerset is a complex fantastical world with a rich history and plenty of conflict.

The Gray Sheep by S. M. Somerset Book Cover

Cosette is doing her best to continue running her father’s jeweler shop in a war-torn country as he recovers from an illness that isn’t getting any better with her uncle in another part of town. When she gets word of his decline, she decides to risk everything to go see him, even though the space between them is occupied and extremely dangerous.

Resourceful, thoughtful, and quite stubborn, Cosette is a worthy heroine. This story is deeply political, as all the marketing materials promise. To be honest, some of it was a little too much for me, and it tended to linger in sections I felt could do with more urgency. The language was urgent in these spaces, but the actual sentences still took their time leaving a strange feeling of needing to move forward, but not being able to because there were just too many words to get through in the scene.

I really admired Cosette’s bravery and determination, and several of the characters she encounters were interesting, and at times unexpected.

Overall, I think people who enjoy the political side of fantasy will enjoy this, or even sweeping historical epics might try their hand at it and be delightfully surprised.

As a whole, it strikes me mostly as quite an accomplishment!

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title::The Gray Sheep (The Lochsmith Book I)
Author::S. M. Somerset
Genre:: Historical Fantasy
Publisher::Indie
Length:: 582 pages
Published::May 5th, 2026
The Litertarian Rating:: 4-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

The Cheesemaker’s Daughter | Kristin Vukovic
Daughter of Ruins | Yvette Manassis Corporon
Divine Rivals | Rebecca Ross

Book Review:: The Relic of the Wildwood | E.J. Venter

A perilous quest. A fierce protector. And a young woman who doesn’t believe she’s enough. These are the ones tasked with saving the world from an evil force none understand. Will they survive long enough to succeed?

The Relic of the Wildwood by EJ Venter Book Cover

The first thing I want to say about this book is how completely engrossed I was from the very beginning. Though there are common fantasy elements in this story, it had a unique feel I can’t quite describe. That’s not to say it’s cookie cutter at all, but I felt like I was reading about something real.

Alarie has no self-confidence because it has all been sapped out of her by her mother, whom I suspect is up to something greater. She is sent to accomplish an impossible task, and one of the greatest warriors in the realm is sworn to protect her, reluctantly, but dutifully. This first book does so much to set the stage for what could truly be an epic tale.

This is a story that has lingered in my mind long after I read, and I’m happy to see book two is already available to read. That’s where you can find me next!

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title::The Relic of the Wildwood (Relics of the Gods Book 1)
Author::E. J. Venter
Genre::Fantasy
Publisher::Indie
Length:: 306 pages
Published::December 15th, 2025
The Litertarian Rating:: 5-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Thief of Night | Holly Black
The Summer War | Naomi Novik
Awake in the Floating City | Susanna Kwan
Anji Kills A King | Evan Leikam

Book Review:: Graceless Heart | Isabel Ibanez

Isabel Ibanez is on my watch list. I’ve truly loved some of her work in the past, so I wasn’t going to miss an opportunity to read her newest book, Graceless Heart.

Graceless Heart by Isabel Ibanez Book Cover

Moving from Egypt in her previous historical fantasy series, this one takes place in Italy, a setting replete with historical potential.

It took a hot minute for the story to grab me, and I still felt like I was sort of bashing my way through a jungle of vines in order to get to the good stuff.

But the good stuff was good. Saturnino was one of those characters where you weren’t entirely sure the entire time if he was someone you could trust. Ibanez is so good at this morally ambiguous love interests! And the finale at the end of the book was truly fascinating and memorable.

If you are new to Ibanez I would honestly recommend her previous duology, beginning with What the River Knows, over this. I found it more immersive and chalk full of adventure and mystery I was more interested in. This one just felt a little too heavy with extraneous world building/political details that, while they may pay off eventually, also had an adverse effect on the story this novel could have been. As a writer myself, I understand the impulse to show off the impeccable world you’ve crafted that the story fits inside of…there just wasn’t enough, as a reader, to grab onto and really care about all those tracks.

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title:: Graceless Heart (The Spellbound History Quartet #1)
Author:: Isabel Ibanez
Genre:: Historical Fantasy
Publisher:: Saturday Books
Length:: 488 pages
Published:: January 13th, 2026
The Litertarian Rating:: 3-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Book Review:: Silver & Blood | Jessie Mihalik

Romantasy fans, this one’s for you. Part fairy tale, part romance, this book is bound to satisfy many romantasy lovers.

Silver & Blood by Jessie Mihalik Book Cover

Riela is taken to an enchanted house in the woods, where she is essentially trapped with a partly terrifying, partly misunderstood brooding powerful man, his wolf companion, and enough magic to protect them from the evils outside. But strange as that is, it becomes ever stranger when she accidentally does the one thing she was told never to do, and opens an entirely new can of worms.

In some ways, this book was refreshing in the face of other romantasy novels, but in others, it’s still the same note. Romantasy heroines are essentially all inter-changable, and I found that to be the case here as well. They’re always doing things they ought naught, having an attitude about it, being stuck in magical situations that barely make any sense at all…

But…

Somehow it is still interesting enough to keep you turning pages. Did I want to know what happened next? Mmhmm. Did I fall in love with Garrick alongside her? Um, duh. Are the politics nothing but window dressing? Of course. But that’s what romantasy readers want, and here, they get it. A fulfilled promise. An entertaining handful of hours. A new series to track.

And will I read the sequel? …probably 🙂

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title:: Silver & Blood (Silber & Blood #1)
Author:: Jessie Mihalik
Genre:: Romantasy
Publisher:: Avon
Length:: 448 pages
Published::January 27th, 2026
The Litertarian Rating:: 3-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Quicksilver | Callie Hart
Rose in Chains | Julie Soto
Heartless Hunter | Kristen Ciccarelli
Divine Rivals | Rebecca Ross

Book Review:: Quicksilver | Callie Hart

I feel like I’m in my romantasy era, and I don’t hate it! Look at the cover of this book. What an absolute killer. For me, Quicksilver lives up to the hype, but it’s not perfect.

This book, and pretty much all romantasy I’ve read, is an absolute whirlwind. I would say I loved it up to the 85% mark or so, when things got a little squirrely and felt almost like another type of book entirely, and I didn’t love that so much. I can’t mention exactly what bugged me without throwing major spoilers, so I won’t. But a new trope essentially was thrown in an already tropey book and…it just wasn’t expected at all by the rest of the story setup. At least by me.

Honestly, I’m super under-read in this genre, and even I could spot the heavy use of popular tropes in this book. I get it, and really I loved most of it despite being a little taken out of the story by those hey, I recognize this moments. But it did feel a little like spaghetti being thrown at a wall. I really don’t want to say the specific complaints I had because they would be major spoilers, but at the 80-85% mark it felt like this book made a major turn I personally did not see coming, and it felt…I don’t know. Half corny, half unnecessary, and a little bit dumb? It took me out of the story so fast. However, I will absolutely still read the rest of this series, so it wasn’t completely…ruinous *smirk*

Speaking of romance: Saeris Fane & Kingfisher. Build me a ship and send me to sea, because hot damn, I loved the enemies to lovers thing going on there, and their…whole deal. If you’re going to write romantasy, you better get the romance right, and Callie Hart nailed it.

I even liked the side characters in this book. Like most romantasy, there’s a lot to keep track of, but it stayed interesting and engaging throughout, and you never feel too lost or confused by mountains of new information. It boils down to Kingfisher being the guardian of his homelands, and the entire world conspiring against his goal, while Saeris Fane might just be the one thing that could help him actually succeed.

Overall, bravo! You have to leave your belief suspended reading a book like this, but it feels like Ms. Hart has her entire basis covered with this one. Everything feels well developed, if not entirely to my taste, but I can’t deny she’s great at her craft! I’ve got my copy of Brimstone pre-ordered!

Details

Title:: Quicksilver (Fae & Alchemy #1)
Author:: Callie Hart
Genre:: Romantasy
Publisher:: Forever
Length:: 624 pages
Audio Length:: 20h 41m
Audiobook Narrator:: Stella Bloom & Anthony Palmini
Published:: December 3rd, 2024
The Litertarian Rating:: 4-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Book Review:: The Everlasting | Alix E. Harrow

I have read over two hundred books this year, and I hope you believe me when I say that this is the best one of them. I don’t know what I thought The Everlasting by Alix E. Harrow was going to be, but I certainly didn’t expect to be adding it to my all-time favorites book list (a very exclusive place). If you only ever read one book that I recommend, please let it be this one.

The Everlasting by Alix E. Harrow Book Cover

The Everlasting is an academic mystery thriller adventure love story hero’s journey epoch/epic legend historical fantasy that is witty and smart and twisted and surprising and endearing and wickedly romantic and I am going to read it again about a million times before I die because that’s the kind of reader I am. I got this book for free through netgalley and the publisher (thanks, by the way), and before I finished, I had ordered myself a limited-edition hardcover so I can study this masterpiece.

Sorry, are book reviews not supposed to be written like school-girl crush-fests? Let’s get into some better detail…

There was once a legend of an orphan girl called Una who was in the right place at the right time and was chosen by a worthy queen as her champion, and she served her as a hero through all the rest of her days. Centuries later, there is a boy with a broken family and a story that has saved him, again and again, from despair. That story is of Una Everlasting. That boy is a scholar, and he is called upon to rewrite Una’s story into a magical book that transports him back to actually meet her and live her story so he can record it with an honesty and integrity that doesn’t exist in our world.

Until he learns the truth.

This book is about heroism is unlikely places. It’s about the boundless nature of love. It’s about power and honor and duty and secrets. It’s about magic and fate and family. About lies and deep, unshakable truths. Its writing is sharp and honestly delightful. The tone is adventurous and fun. There are good guys and bad guys and lots of other guys in between. There is nothing not to like about this book, and it deserves every single one of its five-star reviews.

As an aspiring author myself, Alix, how the hell? This novel is impeccable, immaculate, amazing. Thank you.

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title:: The Everlasting
Author:: Alix E. Harrow
Genre:: Historical Fantasy
Publisher:: Tor Books
Length:: 320 pages
Audio Length:: 13h 41m
Audiobook Narrator:: Moira Quirk & Sid Sagar
Published:: October 28th, 2025
The Litertarian Rating:: 5-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Book Review:: Where the Library Hides | Isabel Ibanez

Where the Library Hides is the second book in the Secrets of the Nile Duology by Isabel Ibanez. If you have not started this wonderful historical fantasy series yet, please start with What the River Knows. If you’ve not read it, the review below may include spoilers.

Where The Library Hides by Isabel Ibanez Book Cover

Inez is in deep with the forgery circuit mystery in Egypt, too deep to ignore – too deep to turn back. The only way she can get out from beneath her uncle’s thumb of control is to marry Mr. Whitford Hays, a cunning man of mystery & deception she’s convinced herself she can trust. But when he betrays her within days of their secret wedding, Inez accepts that only she is in control of her destiny – there is no one left she can trust. If she doesn’t work to preserve the legacy of Cleopatra and other Egyptian relics, no one will. Her fiery a relentless personality is back in full force for this conclusion to the series. But what I love about Inez is that she’s not all fire. She also has so much compassion. She has an open heart for forgiveness and wants to give others the benefit of the doubt, even when they may not deserve it.

In this novel she is put through many trials, and jumps head first into dicey situations many would run away from. She’s brave. She’s strong. She’s noble. And she won’t stop until she succeeds.

Whitford Hays…oh Whit, Whit, Whit…what a rascal you are. Where he is a swashbuckling enigma in the first book, we get to see some deeper layers to the secretive genteel in this second book, and ladies, he’s far from perfect. He makes some big boo boos along the way, but in the end, the romance is as bombastic as we (and they) deserve.

I cannot recommend this series highly enough. The intrigue, the adventure, the tension…all of it is handled masterfully, and I’m not sure how I feel about it ending after only two books. Did it need more? No. But selfishly I want to linger far longer in this world. Luckily I own both books in multiple formats so I can revisit them literally whenever and whereever I want. #readergoals

Read it. Love it. Thank me later.

Details

Title:: Where the Library Hides (Secrets of the Nile #2)
Author:: Isabel Ibanez
Genre:: Historical Fantasy
Publisher:: Wednesday Books
Length:: 400 pages
Audio Length:: 14h 29m
Audiobook Narrator:: Ahmed Hamad and Ana Osorio
Published:: November 5th, 2024
The Litertarian Rating:: 5-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

What the River Knows | Isabel Ibanez
Divine Rivals | Rebecca Ross
The Ministry of Time | Kaliane Bradley

Book Review:: Thief of Night | Holly Black

I just learned that this is the second book in a duology, and suddenly that makes a lot of sense. I saw Holly Black’s name on netgalley and clicked so fast. I haven’t read everything she’s written (obviously) but I know she’s a talented writer and couldn’t wait to get started.

Thief of Night by Holly Black Book Cover

This novel is so unique. I loved the politics of it, the built in mystery, the fascinating magic structure. It’s an intense urban fantasy setting. The characters are interesting and complex and this story was compelling all the way through.

I am so intrigued now to go back and read book one!

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title:: Thief of Night (The Charlatan Duology #2)
Author:: Holly Black
Genre:: Urban Fantasy
Publisher:: Penguin
Length:: 288 pages
Audio Length:: 11h 4m
Audiobook Narrator:: Jonathan Davis, Sara Amini, Vikas Adam
Published:: September 23rd, 2025
The Litertarian Rating:: 5-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Burn for Me | Ilona Andrews
Our Infinite Fates | Laura Steven
The Summer War | Naomi Novik

Book Review:: The Summer War | Naomi Novik

In this brief novella by Naomi Novik, the full story of a curse is told. There are kingdoms with long feuds and high emotions, and ultimately it is up to a young girl, and few others, to break the two kingdoms out of inevitable war.

The Summer War by Naomi Novik Book Cover

If you are a big fan of political fantasy, this is your jam. There is a lot of politics and explanation of history between the two nations in this novella. For me, there wasn’t enough of the internal conflict explored on the page. We understand Celia’s motivations, but I never felt them, you know?

Overall, it’s a successful story. We walk from the very beginnings of the conflict to the technically perfect resolution. It just felt a little empty of emotion for me. I’m not sure how else to say it.

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title:: The Summer War
Author:: Naomi Novik
Genre:: Fantasy
Publisher:: Del Rey
Length:: 144 pages
Audio Length:: 3h 47m
Audiobook Narrator:: Ella Lynch
Published:: September 16, 2025
The Litertarian Rating:: 3-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Book Review:: The Book of Lost Hours | Hayley Gelfuso

A big idea can change the world, for what is the world as we know it, but ideas? It starts small, inside the mind of one person, who grapples with it, tries to fully understand it, articulate it into words to share with another mind, who will poke and it, test it, expand it. Some of them wither and die under scrutiny, and others balloon with importance and have the power to change the world as we know it. Democracy. Germ theory. And in the case of The Book of Lost Hours, the manipulation of time.

The Book of Lost Hours by Hayley Gelfuso Book Cover

This book is a wonder. Any book about time is going to bend our ideas of a timeline, and this one plays with the strings of time beautifully, skillfully, coherently, it will have you enthralled. This is a page turning thriller with so much heart and intellectual stimulation it will grip you and not let go until the final dang sentence.

It’s also the kind of book with twists and turns and the simple joys of small discoveries. With that, I don’t want to spoil one detail of the plot for those of you who go on to read this, which I very much recommend you do. It is marketed as a mashup of The Ministry of Time and The Midnight Library and I could not come up with a better description of this impressive novel.

Hayley Gelfuso, you are a genius and I think I will pick up anything you put down. Also, what do you mean this is a debut novel. Masterful work. Thank you, sincerely, for writing this fascinating book.

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title:: The Book of Lost Hours
Author:: Hayley Gelfuso
Genre:: Sci-Fi/Fantasy Romance
Publisher:: Atria Books
Length:: 400 pages
Audio Length:: 13h 41m
Audiobook Narrator:: Carlotta Brentan
Published:: August 26th, 2025
The Litertarian Rating:: 5-Stars