An ancient prophecy, a school for magicians, a brutal war – written by popular author Julie Soto – Rose in Chains is a highly anticipated summer romantasy release. But for me, there wasn’t enough to justify a high rating. Like, literally not enough substance to hold onto. There are some spoilers included in my review, but looks like most of it is included in the promotional materials so do with that warning what you will. Continue at your own risk!

So there is a war between these two factions of people, but only kind of? There is a big battle in which the main character’s brother, who was prophesied to save them, is lost. Then everyone from that kingdom is captured and essentially sold to be sex slaves to boost the magic of the new regime who is this evil lady with vicious mind reading capabilities.
I just…don’t get it. Almost nothing actually happens in the book. There seems to be a lot of angst, and well earned, but it’s also largely just a bunch of orgy parties where some potentially useful information is traded…sometimes? Everything is shrouded in secrecy, which makes sense because of the mind reading…but still. We have almost no context of the war once Briony is in her new placement of what the war is, where it is, or why it is.
Instead we have flashbacks back to days at school where there were some interactions between the two lead characters, but still…seemed largely unnecessary? It was kind of a lot of flailing around by Briony while she tries to figure out why she is being treated differently than the other sex/magic drain slaves and what happened to her friends. The main concerns seem to be retaining Briony’s virginity and ability to sire children in some unknown future while everyone else seems to be ultra-focused on Toven’s de-flowering her and pulling in her magic.
There is heart magic and mind magic and they’re totally separate, but also, pretty much all the characters can dip into each of them? Eh. Interesting, but kind of muddly in the execution.
But seriously, why is every single review of this book 5 stars with exuberant praise? To me everything it tried to do was mediocre at best. Is the idea of this seriously brooding unknown guy being halfway decent and protective that much of a draw that it can make up for having almost no plot to speak of? Really? I thought we could do better than that at this point in the romantasy novel timeline. Guess it’s just me though.
I do like the cover, and the audiobook narrator did a great job, but this one just wasn’t for me.
Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Details
Title:: Rose in Chains (The Evermore Trilogy #1)
Author:: Julie Soto
Genre:: Romantasy
Publisher:: Forever
Length:: 464 pages
Audio Length:: 16h 1m
Audiobook Narrator:: Ella Lynch
Published:: July 8th, 2025
The Litertarian Rating:: 2.5-Stars (generously)
If you liked this book, check out…
Heartless Hunter | Kristin Ciccarelli
Our Infinite Fates | Laura Steven