4-Star Archives - The Litertarian

Book Review:: Quicksilver | Callie Hart

I feel like I’m in my romantasy era, and I don’t hate it! Look at the cover of this book. What an absolute killer. For me, Quicksilver lives up to the hype, but it’s not perfect.

This book, and pretty much all romantasy I’ve read, is an absolute whirlwind. I would say I loved it up to the 85% mark or so, when things got a little squirrely and felt almost like another type of book entirely, and I didn’t love that so much. I can’t mention exactly what bugged me without throwing major spoilers, so I won’t. But a new trope essentially was thrown in an already tropey book and…it just wasn’t expected at all by the rest of the story setup. At least by me.

Honestly, I’m super under-read in this genre, and even I could spot the heavy use of popular tropes in this book. I get it, and really I loved most of it despite being a little taken out of the story by those hey, I recognize this moments. But it did feel a little like spaghetti being thrown at a wall. I really don’t want to say the specific complaints I had because they would be major spoilers, but at the 80-85% mark it felt like this book made a major turn I personally did not see coming, and it felt…I don’t know. Half corny, half unnecessary, and a little bit dumb? It took me out of the story so fast. However, I will absolutely still read the rest of this series, so it wasn’t completely…ruinous *smirk*

Speaking of romance: Saeris Fane & Kingfisher. Build me a ship and send me to sea, because hot damn, I loved the enemies to lovers thing going on there, and their…whole deal. If you’re going to write romantasy, you better get the romance right, and Callie Hart nailed it.

I even liked the side characters in this book. Like most romantasy, there’s a lot to keep track of, but it stayed interesting and engaging throughout, and you never feel too lost or confused by mountains of new information. It boils down to Kingfisher being the guardian of his homelands, and the entire world conspiring against his goal, while Saeris Fane might just be the one thing that could help him actually succeed.

Overall, bravo! You have to leave your belief suspended reading a book like this, but it feels like Ms. Hart has her entire basis covered with this one. Everything feels well developed, if not entirely to my taste, but I can’t deny she’s great at her craft! I’ve got my copy of Brimstone pre-ordered!

Details

Title:: Quicksilver (Fae & Alchemy #1)
Author:: Callie Hart
Genre:: Romantasy
Publisher:: Forever
Length:: 624 pages
Audio Length:: 20h 41m
Audiobook Narrator:: Stella Bloom & Anthony Palmini
Published:: December 3rd, 2024
The Litertarian Rating:: 4-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Book Review:: Mile High | Liz Tomforde

Welcome to the best sports romance series I’ve read. In the Windy City series, Liz Tomforde has created an irresistable cast of characters you can’t help but love. They’re eclectic, they’re flawed, they’re possessive, quite spicy, and you want to be friends with every last one of them. The first in the series is probably the sassiest and perhaps the most transformational of them all. In my opinion, every book only gets better than the last, and you can’t ask for better than that!

Zanders is the ladiest of ladies men. As in, he’s got numbers for ladies in every city his professional hockey team visits. Multiple ladies. In every town. He’s a player, and he’s not ashamed of it. But when their new flight attendant, Stevie, refuses to take any of his shit, he’s curious, and then obsessed with cracking through her tough shell. Too bad she’s completely unimpressed with professional athletes since her twin brother is one of the biggest NBA stars in the country.

“You following me?”

What do I love about this book? Both of these characters are challenged and go through a lot of big growth. I appreciate that Stevie can be insecure about her body, and I absolutely love that Zanders only has heart eyes for every inch of her. There are bumps and bruises along the way, but they both really get a quick sense of each other and are able to care for one another intuitively from pretty early on. Not only do they grow together, they go through their own personal transformations, too, that pave the way for a healthy relationship.

I love that these books are so long and detailed. Everything feels very connected and weaved together, and not splotchy and clumsily tied together. You really get to spend a lot of time with the characters and their world, so you get a really great payoff in the end when things finally click into place.

Any fan of romance should give this series the good try. I haven’t seen a single person who disliked them yet. There are FIVE books to enjoy (I can’t wait to enjoy the last one after my reread of the rest!), and I cannot wait to see what Liz Tomforde comes up with next! Let’s get it girl!

Details

Title:: Mile High (Windy City #1)
Author:: Liz Tomforde
Genre:: Sports Romance
Publisher:: Indie
Length:: 603 pages
Audio Length:: 16h 48m
Audiobook Narrator:: Winston James and Mari
Published:: June 4th, 2022
The Litertarian Rating:: 4-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Play Along | Liz Tomforde
The Graham Effect | Elle Kennedy
Gloves Off | Stephanie Archer

Book Review:: My Husband’s Wife | Alice Feeney

This is my second Alice Feeney novel, and it is just as twisty and confusing and unreliable as the last one! If you’re a fan of high stakes puzzles and layers of mystery and suspense, you’re going to love her new release, My Husband’s Wife.

My Husband's Wife by Alice Feeney Book Cover

Eden Fox comes home from a run to find a stranger in her house. Her key doesn’t work, and there’s a lookalike there, dressed in her clothes, kissing her husband. It’s impossible, but it’s happening. Even the police don’t believe her, and everything she might have had for proof was left inside the house before her run.

This is the start of one of the most complex webs of confusion, mystery, and deception I’ve ever read. There is twist after twist and no shortage of suspicions, and just when you think you know what happened, everything turns on its head all over again.

This is the kind of book the term ‘page-turner’ was invented for. Though at times it was so shrouded in so many layers that it took awhile for the clarity to sink in, it is very good at what it does, which is satisfy your craving for a compelling story.

I was able to experience the audiobook version of this novel. It is produced to a slightly higher level than a typical book, and overall I really enjoyed all those additions. However, as someone who listens at a faster speed than 1x, the running sound effect was really frantic. For that reason I would recommend reading it on 1x speed.

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title:: My Huband’s Wife
Author:: Alice Feeney
Genre:: Mystery Thriller
Publisher:: Flatiron Books
Length:: 320 pages
Audio Length:: 8h 58m
Audiobook Narrator:: Bel Powley, Henry Rowley, and Richard Armitage
Published:: January 20th, 2026
The Litertarian Rating:: 4-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Where He Left Me | Nicole Baart
Remain | Nicholas Sparks & M. Night Shyamalan
Listen for the Lie | Amy Tintera

Book Review:: Lovelight Farms | BK Borison

I think we can all agree that BK Borison is great at what she does: swoony contemporary romances with heart and spice and all the feels. And it started all the way back with her debut, Lovelight Farms. If you’re a romance reader and haven’t read BK Borison yet, literally what are you doing. STOP, pick this up, and begin your education on what an excellent contemporary romance can be.

Lovelight Farms by BK Borison Book Cover

To be honest, I did not fall for this book the first time I read it. There is a bit of a mystery storyline that distracts from the angsty longing that cracks and sparkles between Luca and Stella which is the real star of the show.

These two ran into each other years ago and became fast friends. He lives in New York though, which is close enough to visit often, but a little unrealistic for a serious intimate relationship. Besides, Stella has abandonment issues that keep her from being outright with her feelings. Now though, she’s in a pinch. She’s told a social media influencer she owns her Christmas tree farm with her true love to pump up their story and win the contest she desperately needs to win to stay afloat. Trouble is, she and Luca have only ever been friends, and now she has to tell him what she did so that he can play along. What could go wrong? It’s just acting, right?

This is the perfect time of year to pick up this book. It’s about a Christmas tree farm. They’re always buying each other coffees. It’s a small town. It’s cozy as hell. But that’s just the ambiance. To me, the romance is everything and the friends to more trajectory is just so achingly sweet. Stella and Luca absolutely won me over, and look at that stinkin’ cute cover!

If you find yourself here in holiday season 2025 and still haven’t read this book, seriously, add it to your reading list. I don’t think you’ll be disappointed.

Details

Title:: Lovelight Farms (Lovelight #1)
Author:: BK Borison
Genre:: Holiday Romance
Publisher:: Berkley
Length:: 336 pages
Audio Length:: 10h 15m
Audiobook Narrator:: Pippa Jayne
Published:: June 6th, 2023
The Litertarian Rating:: 4-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Christmas Is All Around | Martha Waters
Mistletoe & Mr Right | Sarah Morgenthaler
First Time Caller | BK Borison
Business Casual | BK Borison

Book Review:: The Book Club Boyfriend | Kendall Ryan

Another Kendall Ryan delight today in The Book Club Boyfriend!

The Book Club Boyfriend by Kendall Ryan book cover

Scarlett is a jaded author stuck in a rut, and when she goes on live TV to chat with Chase Remington, a pro hockey player, fans go wild and demand more. Chase leads a book club for the team for good PR, and now Scarlett is roped into participating.

This author is so good at creating tension between characters, and compared to the other title I read of hers this month (Checking It Twice), this one was far less spicy and far more slow burn, which is also really satisfying, just different.

One thing I found a little odd about this one is how far into their relationship we got. I’m wondering if Ms. Ryan was extra attached to these two characters, because they got about a million epilogues 🙂

You can’t really go wrong with Kendall Ryan. If you’re a fan of hockey romance or you like reading characters in the book industry, this one is a no brainer.

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title:: The Book Club Boyfriend (Must Love Hockey #2)
Author:: Kendall Ryan
Genre:: Sports Romance
Publisher:: Dream Press
Length:: 352 pages
Audio Length:: 7h 30m
Audiobook Narrator:: Ryan West & CJ Bloom
Published:: November 11th, 2025
The Litertarian Rating:: 4-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Checking It Twice | Kendall Ryan (coming soon)
A Beginner’s Guide to Forever | Kendall Ryan
When Alec Met Evie | Jenny Proctor

Book Review:: Checking It Twice | Kendall Ryan

Friends, I’ve found you a lovely, swoony, holiday romance that will warm you up better than a cup of hot cocoa. It’s Checking It Twice by Kendall Ryan.

Clare works in PR for a hockey team in Dallas, and she’s really good at setting boundaries with those wild boys with her wit and sharp tongue. But as the holidays near, and Clare will be alone, again, it makes her a little reckless.

Checking It Twice by Kendall Ryan Book Cover

Mitchell Drake is heartbroken. Or at least, everyone thinks he is including his immediate family and his entire home town in Minnesota. He can’t seem to make them understand that he’s better off, so he comes up with an unconventional plan, but he can’t do it alone.

Clare would never do something so reckless and deceitful as fake date someone…except when she’s at an emotional rock bottom. But it’s okay, because even though he’s the hottest player on the team, they both understand what this is: temporary. Not real.

If you have ever like the fake dating trope or are a fan of sports romance, this is an automatic win for you. Kendall Ryan has mastered sizzling chemistry, and the character backstory work done here to make these two lovebirds into soulmates is phenomenal.

There was only one thing that kind of nagged at me and that was in the beginning chapters they all kind of ended the exact same way, restating the character’s weakening fortifications. Some of them felt pretty identical, and though it’s a satisfying way to end a chapter, so many in a row that were almost verbatim stood out to me.

Kendall Ryan is a master of her craft, and I can’t wait to read more of her work!

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title:: Checking it Twice (Must Love Hockey #3)
Author:: Kendall Ryan
Genre:: Holiday Sports Romance
Publisher:: Dreamscape Media
Length:: 343 pages
Audio Length:: 7h 56m
Audiobook Narrator:: Grayson Owens & Rose Dioro
Published:: November 25th, 2025
The Litertarian Rating:: 4-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

My Favorite Holidate | Lauren Blakely
Happy Christmas | Kelsey Humphreys
Yours for the Season | Emily Stone

Book Review:: Secret Nights and Northern Lights | Megan Oliver

Mona is always overlooked. In a busy family with twin boys less than a year older than she is, their parents were always too exhausted for her to get any one-on-one attention. She learned never to stick out, never to rock the boat, to be nice and easy and invisible, the way everyone wanted her to be. She still does, in a way, as a writer at a travel magazine. She’s done her duty for years while being overlooked for the job she wants the most: International travel.

Secret Nights and Northern Lights by Megan Oliver Book Cover

Finally, she gets the opportunity to go to Iceland – all the other international writers are on other trips, and the magazine has the opportunity to work with one of the best photographers around. The problem is, she knows him. She knows him very well. In fact, he’s the boy she grew up with, fell in love with, the only one who ever saw her. So she thought, before he shattered her heart into a million pieces. Now, if she wants the job she’s always dreamed of, she’s got to go on this picturesque trip with him. But can they go the whole week without confronting their past?

Ben walking back into her life brings up a lot of repressed emotions from Mona. Not only from their own relationship, dynamic, and drama, but of the way she was back then. She knew him forever. They lived a few houses down, and they were in the same class starting in kindergarten. He knows her, he knows her family, he’s friends with her parents, and he’s the perfect person to bounce these feelings off of.

She felt a little bit manic almost, at times. She would bring things up with Ben, he would be a great and sympathetic listener-then she would shut down and act like he somehow was the one bringing this stuff up. But it was her. Every single time. Ben wanted to talk about the big stuff, but he never once pushed her. He just said (paraphrased) ‘we need to talk about this before we’re done with this trip’, and she ran away from it every single time. The snip-snap of it all was a little frustrating. However, it wasn’t a deal breaker, it just made me not like Mona so much.

I love second chance romance stories as long as they have a justified break, genuine misunderstandings that AREN’T just a bad miscommunication trope, and I was overall very pleased with this one. The backstory was interesting and had a lot of depth, and these two characters really seemed to love each other, both then and now.

It’s also a destination/travel romance, did I mention? There are lots of scenes of fun and adventurous activities in Iceland.

Another worthwhile romance from Berkley! I will be interested in following Megan Oliver to see what she comes up with next. I smelled a sequel featuring one of Mona’s brothers, but time will tell!

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title:: Secret Nights and Northern Lights
Author:: Megan Oliver
Genre:: Contemporary Romance
Publisher:: Berkley
Length:: 384 pages
Audio Length:: 10h 44m
Audiobook Narrator:: Brittany Pressley
Published:: November 18th, 2025
The Litertarian Rating:: 4-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Adam and Evie’s Matchmaking Tour | Nora Nguyen
PS I Hate You } Lauren Connolly
How to Hide in Plain Sight | Emma Noyes

Book Review:: My Favorite Holidate | Lauren Blakely

When your guy-for-now blatantly cheats on you at a party, you get your revenge by fake-dating your billionaire boss. Obviously. Except you’ve had a thing for said billionaire boss for awhile, and he’s a hot single dad with a compassionate heart. It might be hard not to get caught up in the illusion.

My Favorite Holidate by Lauren Blakely Book Cover

Lauren Blakely is so good at these trope-stuffed romance novels. This is the kind of book you go to when you want a guaranteed romance knockout that isn’t that deep, but will hit you right in the feels every time.

Throw in some holiday cheer, and you’ve got yourself a winner.

If you’re a fan of fake dating, I think this is one you’re going to like. It’s a hard trope to pull off, in my opinion, but Blakely is a pro and handles it well.

This steamy and spicy romance will keep you warm on those cold winter nights!

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title:: My Favorite Holidate (How to Date #5)
Author:: Lauren Blakely
Genre:: Holiday Romance
Publisher:: Atria
Length:: 384 pages
Audio Length:: 13h 22m
Audiobook Narrator:: Full Cast
Published:: October 15th, 2025
The Litertarian Rating:: 4-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Yours for the Season | Emily Stone
Happy Christmas | Kelsey Humphreys
Pitcher Perfect | Tess Bailey

Book Review:: Where He Left Me | Nicole Baart

Sadie Sheridan almost gave up on finding the one. But then, in her 40s, she fell in love with another professor at her university. Felix. He’s smart, and quirky, and sweeps her off her feet. Once they’re married, he sweeps her off to the remote mountain cabin he grew up in. Then, he disappears.

Where He Left Me by Nicole Baart Book Cover

Sadie is alone, and terrified. Winter is coming, and her husband should be home from his conference by now. It’s her first time in a place like this, and she doesn’t know the first thing about life on the mountain.

Then one of the trail cam’s picks something up. A shadowy figure in the woods, and it’s headed for her property.

Where He Left Me is masterful suspense novel. Every sentence is dripping with mystery and tension and I had no idea where the story was going. I wouldn’t have been surprised at anything with how much tension was set up in this book. What ended up happening though, was a very endearing story of strength, determination, and mama bear energy.

There were a few things that bothered me, ultimately, which is why I’ve rated it four stars instead of five. I don’t want to spoil anything though, so I will keep them to myself. Was it still worth reading though? Absolutely. Especially in these new dark days of fall/early winter, this is the perfect type of book to curl up with and get lost in the suspense!

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title:: Where He Left Me
Author:: Nicole Baart
Genre:: Suspense Thriller
Publisher:: Atria Books
Length:: 336 pages
Audio Length:: 11h 36m
Audiobook Narrator:: Amanda Dolan
Published:: November 4th, 2025
The Litertarian Rating:: 4-Stars

If you liked this book, check out…

Book Review:: Never Over | Clare Gilmore

I’ve been a massive fan of Clare Gilmore since I read Perfect Fit last year. That book is *chef’s kiss*. I don’t know what it is about books about music that kind of turn me off, but I didn’t let that stop me from enjoying her newest release, Never Over.

Here we have another wonderful second chance romance. Paige is a songwriter living in Tennessee who is struggling to break into the industry. Her big break comes with a music exec finally comes by to listen to her tunes. He realizes she’s a phenomenal talent for melody, but her lyrics don’t quite hit the way they could. That’s not a surprise to her, considering her heart has been walled off ever since her catastrophic breakup with Liam.

She’s not too proud to go to him and ask if they can strike up a new fling so she might be inspired again, the way he once inspired her.

I’m not the greatest fan of the setup here, however, I can appreciate that this is the fake dating trope without actually being fake dating. I love Liam for laying out in their rules that this is real. He can’t fake it with her. But they will leave the end date a nebulous thing. Whatever happens, happens. So, basically, like any relationship. It’s a risk. Things might light up, they might burn to the ground.

We’re taken back and forth between the present timeline, with Paige trying to write new music and lyrics, and the past, when writing music was only a hobby and her best friend was Liam the baseball pitcher extraordinaire, not Liam the roadie.

The connection between the two of them is inevitable. They’re electric, which is my favorite thing to find in a romance novel. Especially their physical connection, wink wink. Yes, there is some spice here. But they both have some issues to work through, both in past and present timelines, in order to lock in for the long haul.

In conclusion! I very much enjoyed this book (though it hasn’t quite knocked Perfect Fit from the number one spot). If you’re looking for a tension laden romantic story to hold you over – this one is a great choice!

Note:: I received an early copy of this book from the publisher through netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Details

Title:: Never Over
Author:: Clare Gilmore
Genre:: Contemporary Romance
Publisher:: St. Martin’s Griffin
Length:: 352 pages
Audio Length:: 10h 52m
Audiobook Narrator:: Carly Robins
Published:: October 28th, 2025
The Litertarian Rating:: 4-Stars